Anonymous asked:

You , Axel and even now Joe seem to talk a lot of shit about the Sept Solicitations from DC but look at what you guys are doing to Jim Starlin and what you did with Greg Rucka , Matt Fractions Inhuman and George Martin and I can go on how you consort in the same type of actions. Yes Dc is about writers and the silly covers but what I see Marvel doing is also wrong. Especially how you treat BMB better than everyone because he's been your cash cow please stop throwing stones from a glass house sir

brevoortformspring answered:

Wait, what?

JIm Starlin came back and did an OGN, and then an Annual, and then an arc on a book that’s launching. While he’s frustrated because there’s something he wants to do that he can’t do at the moment, on a series that was never approved, that’s hardly a list of infractions.

Greg Rucka is so upset about his awful treatment that he’s writing CYCLOPS at the moment. Matt’s so upset hat he keeps coming to the Marvel summits to share his ideas freely and contribute to the process.

And George RR Martin? We haven’t even talked to the man!

So I have to say, this sort of thinking is beyond bogus. It’s ridiculous. It’s a by-product of the manner in which you fans sometimes confuse the creators and editors with the characters, and want eveybody’s trading card to either clearly say “super hero” or “super villain” on it.

it is always easier to side with the creator whose work you love, especially when you don’t really have but the slightest inking about what is actually going on—and, in fact, there is likely not 1/10th of the drama to the situation as you’re imagining. We don’t have fight scenes in our offices.

We work in a creative industry. In such an environment, not everybody can get everything that they want. Nor is anybody entitled to it. That applies to everybody on both sides of the desk, from Stan lee down to the newbie walking in the door for the first time.

None of which has anything to do with my specific complaint about DC’s September plans.

But as always, you are free to take your time and your dollars wherever you like. If what other people are doing is of greater interest to you, or if the stories you’re imagining in your head about how we’re whipping Jim and Greg and Matt and George are so off-putting that you cannot bring yourself to pick up a Marvel book, so be it. You don’t need to justify your choice to me.